Brown Butter, Mushroom and Pumpkin Pasta

Who’s ready for some fall flavors?

I know I am!

As much as I love experimenting with flavors and creating new recipes, there is just something about fall flavors that excites me for the holiday season. Call it basic if you want, but I call it comfort. Think about taking a cold walk through Bryant Park with a cup of hot spiked apple cider in your hands or your first bite into a maple glazed doughnut. These flavors that signify the change in season are filled with so much warmth. They represent the joy of the holiday season. During the holiday season, I like to treat my friends and family with that same warm comfort feeling. I infuse my apartment with spiced candles, I host dinner parties, bake spiced bread, make hearty soups, and try to fill my home with heartwarming energy. To me, there is nothing more comforting than a bowl of this brown butter mushroom and pumpkin pasta.

For some context, Banza Pasta sent me some of their new bowtie pasta to try out. Alongside of that was a new pumpkin pasta recipe they had recommended. That’s what inspired me to make my own version of a pumpkin pasta. And boy am I glad I did. My version of this recipe, is earthy yet delicate. Filled with all that good fall flavor. This was a crowd pleaser and I’m excited to share why!

Browned butter is honestly one of the most magical secret ingredients. Try it in cookies, pasta, bread, and more. I’m telling you, it. will. change. your. life. It seems to enhance any sweet or savory flavor- adding a rich nutty taste.

In this recipe, I used Cremini Mushrooms. Creminis have such a distinct earthy taste, with a delicate texture and pale brown color. They are basically a more mature version of a white button mushroom. Therefore, they have a lot more flavor and a low moisture content. Win. Win. Because you can brown them beautifully in butter and infuse them in all your favorite herbs for an extra boost in flavor.

Speaking of herbs, let’s talk about sage. If you’re not a fan of the sage, brown butter situation that goes on in this sauce then lets reevaluate your life choices… I mean… its the definition of a mouth watering luxurious sauce! Sage is sweet and somewhat bitter, with a pine-like flavor and aroma. All together, with the brown butter, mushrooms, and pumpkin, this is one dish you’ll definitely want to break out for every dinner party this season.

ProTips:

  • Let the butter brown before adding in the sage. Because it takes a little more patience to brown butter, it will allow you to get the rich nutty caramelized flavor without burning the delicate herb.
  • Don’t use any oil when cooking your mushrooms. Your mushrooms will release a lot of liquid and will cook in that themselves. If you use oil, they will just absorb it like a sponge!
  • Pasta water is a chef’s liquid gold. As soon as your pasta is cooked and ready to drain, scoop out a cup of that pasta water and save it for thinning out your sauce if needed.
  • The recipe calls for a “a handful” of sage. Cooking is all about what tastes right to you! I honestly would rather not have you count 8-12 leaves of sage but instead pick what seems like a handful to you and run with that.

Brown Butter, Mushroom and Pumpkin Pasta

  • Servings: 4
  • Difficulty: easy
  • Print

Ingredients:
-1 box of your favorite pasta
-0.45lbs of sliced cremini mushrooms
-2 1/2 tbsp unsalted butter
-4 minced garlic cloves
-a handful of sage
-1 1/4 cups of pumpkin puree
-1/2 cup or parmesan cheese
-2 cups of heavy milk
Pinch of salt
Pinch of sugar
Black pepper to taste

Directions:
1. Cook the pasta as instructed on the box.
2. In a pan, cook the mushrooms on medium heat until browned.
3. Once cooked, remove from the pan and set aside for later.
4. In the same pan with the leftover mushroom bits on the bottom, add the butter and set to medium heat again.
5. Continuously whisk the butter and watch for brown color and nutty aroma.
6. Once the butter is a light brown color, add the sage and garlic. Cook these until the leaves are soft and aromatic.
7. Mix in the pumpkin puree and heavy milk.
8. Slowly whisking until everything is well combined and set to simmer.
9. Add a pinch of salt, sugar, and black pepper.
10. Add the parmesan while continuing to stir to avoid clumps.
11. Add the mushrooms back into the pan and let simmer for 5 minutes.
12. In a large bowl, toss the pasta and sauce.
13. While mixing, slowly add 1/4 cup of the pasta water to thin out the sauce.
14. Plate and sprinkle on some extra parmesan as well as pinch of flaked salt.

Enjoy!

2 Comments Add yours

  1. Yum! That is so perfect for fall!

    Like

Leave a comment